Opera Scotland

La bohème in Scotland

Posted 30 Jul 2025

La Bohème was first performed in Scotland (under the title The Bohemians) on 30 April 1897 at the Theatre Royal, Glasgow. As the title suggests, the performance was given in English, a policy set for his touring company in 1873 by its founder Carl Rosa.

Just eight days previously in Manchester, Carl Rosa Opera had given the first British performance attended by Puccini himself, as well as his publisher, Tito Ricordi. The Glasgow soloists were identical. The conductor was Claude Jaquinot, and the cast was headed by a leading American soprano as Mimì. Alice Esty, having already sung at the Met, had now made her home in Britain. The other principals included Robert Cunningham (Rodolfo), William Paull (Marcello), Arthur Winckworth (Colline), Charles Tilbury (Schaunard) and Bessie Macdonald (Musetta).

The critic from the Glasgow Herald, ending his lengthy and enthusiastic review on 1 May, said: ‘The Carl Rosa Opera Company have produced operas, which, after a brief season, passed out of the bill. The Bohemians, we venture to think, has come to stay.’

Despite this perceptive comment, it took a while for the piece to catch on. The next Scottish performances, by the Moody-Manners Company, were not until 1907, when the Italian conductor, Romualdo Sapio, led a cast that included his American wife, another Met veteran, Clementine de Vere Sapio, as Mimì. The Rodolfo was a very important British tenor, John Coates. When Fanny Moody and her husband Charles Manners retired, one of their leading tenors, Joseph O’Mara, started his own company, taking on many of the same singers. They gave their first performance of La bohème in 1917, at Her Majesty’s Theatre, Dundee, with O’Mara himself as Rodolfo.

It was between the wars that the opera’s popularity became established. The Carl Rosa and O’Mara companies continued to present it. There was also Sir Thomas Beecham’s company, succeeded in 1922 by the British National Opera Company, which in turn was relaunched as the Covent Garden Opera in 1929. The BNOC, in particular, toured beyond the central belt, performing in both Dundee and Aberdeen. The conductor for many of the Bohème performances at this time was the young John Barbirolli, already recognized as an idiomatic Puccini conductor. Among the Scottish singers to appear at this time were the soprano Noël Eadie (Mimì), tenor Joseph Hislop (Rodolfo) and bass William Anderson (Colline).

While the post-war years were dominated first by the Carl Rosa and then by Sadler’s Wells, the 1950s also saw several visits by a touring company from Italy. It boasted several star soloists, including tenor Gianni Raimondi (Rodolfo) and sopranos Virginia Zeani and Margherita Carosio (both as Mimì). The tenor Charles Craig was a leading singer with Carl Rosa, while several Australian sopranos, including Joan Hammond and Elizabeth Fretwell, appeared with Sadler’s Wells. The Wells brought Bohème north on six of their tours with a staging originally under the direction of Tyrone Guthrie. Their 1958 visit, covering all four of the Scottish cities, was conducted by young Alexander Gibson. Among the regular company members were several notable Scots at the start of their careers. These included tenors William McAlpine and William Aitken (Rodolfo), as well as basses Harold Blackburn and David Ward (Colline).

Scottish Opera tackled the work for the first time­­ in 1967. Gibson conducted, under the direction of Peter Ebert, with the cast setting off excellent traditional designs by Peter Rice. For the second act café scene the chorus was meticulously rehearsed to walk around the stage while singing, so that the vocal sections became mixed up and the sound blended very freshly - apparently a novelty at the time. Rodolfo was sung by the young American tenor George Shirley, recently introduced with enormous success at the Met, and the popular Lebanese soprano Luisa Bosabalian was Mimì. The staging was revived several times in the seventies, with excellent Scottish singers appearing. These included Linda Esther Gray (Mimì), Patricia Hay (Musetta), Marie Slorach (both roles in different revivals), Ronald Morrison (Marcello), William McCue (Colline) and Gordon Sandison (Schaunard). Sir Charles Groves conducted some performances of notable subtlety.

The company’s second production in 1988 was a meticulously detailed staging by Elijah Moshinsky, designed by Michael Yeargan. John Mauceri conducted a cast that included Jane Eaglen (Mimì), Jorge Pita (Rodolfo), Susan Burghardt (Musetta) and Steven Page (Marcello). At various later revivals, singers who appeared included Simon Keenlyside (as both Marcello and Schaunard), Francesca Pedaci (Mimì), Richard Paul Fink and Gordon Sandison (Marcello), Patrick Power, Peter Bronder and Ian Storey (Rodolfo) and Roderick Williams (Schaunard).

Scottish Opera’s third staging in 2004 offered a more radical view, Stewart Laing’s concept taking in a New York loft apartment with garish lighting and modern dress. The conductor was Richard Farnes, with a natural sense of style, and the cast included Rachel Hynes (Mimì), Peter Auty (Rodolfo), Roderick Williams (Marcello), Alessandro Guerzoni (Colline) and Roland Wood (Schaunard). The 2010 revival, conducted by Francesco Corti, introduced Celine Byrne and Avi Klemberg as Mimì and Rodolfo.

Scottish Opera also mounted small or medium-scale touring productions in 1973 and 1977 (both as part of Opera for All); then 1987, 1995 and 2001 (revived in 2002 and 2006).  Casting was invariably done with a range of promising youngsters - for instance the 1995 version, with Jeremy Silver at the piano, took Ian Storey (Rodolfo) and Roderick Williams (Marcello) round the country in a staging by Stewart Laing that kicked off in Dundee.  In 2001 Roland Wood was Marcello, with Ian Shaw, more recently director of The Mozartists, at the keyboard.

The present Scottish Opera staging opened at Glasgow Theatre Royal in 2017.  The Canadian production team of Renaud Doucet and André Barbe set the piece in 1920s Paris.  Stuart Stratford conducted a cast led by Hye-Youn Lee (Mimì) and Luis Gomes (Rodolfo).  David Stout and Jeanine de Bique were Marcello and Musetta, with Damien Pass (Colline) and Božidar Smiljanic (Schaunard).

Particularly in recent years, the opera has been seen in Scotland with great frequency. Full-scale performances have been imported from Eastern Europe by Ellen Kent, and toured widely.  Notable soloists (largely from Moldova and Ukraine) have included Ruslan Zinevych and Vitalii Liskovetskyi (Rodolfo), Irina Vinogradova and Elena Dee (Mimì) and Vladimir Dragos and Petru Racovita (Marcello).  The conductor was usually the excellent Moldovan Nicolae Dohotaru.

There have also been small-scale ventures by several groups of young professionals that tour the UK, notably the Scottish company Opera Bohemia.

English Touring Opera brought a staging to the Perth Festival in 2015, with a cast led by David Butt Philip (Rodolfo), Nicholas Lester (Marcello), Ilona Domnich (Mimì) and Sky Ingram (Musetta). James Conway's production was conducted by Michael Rosewell.

Until recently, the only Bohème-free zone was the Edinburgh International Festival, which ignored the opera throughout its first sixty-nine years of existence. That changed in 2017, with the visit for the seventieth Festival of the opera company from Turin that first launched the work in 1896.  The conductor was Gianandrea Noseda in a highly elaborate staging directed by Alex Ollé.  Rodolfo was sung by Giorgio Berrugi and Iván Ayón Rivas, with Erika Grimaldi and Francesca Sassu alternating as Mimì.  Other singers included Simone del Savio (Marcello), Nicola Ulivieri (Colline), Benjamin Cho (Schaunard) and Kelebogile Besong (Musetta).